The entire country was paranoid and people would step off the footpath when meeting others during the terrifying early days of Covid, a judge said on Tuesday when ruling on a €75,000 claim for defamation against superstore chain Lidl.
Computer software analyst Maciek Molisak told Judge James McCourt in the Circuit Civil Court that a manager in the Kildare Town branch had accused him of spreading disease in the store.
He told his barrister, Conor Kearney, the accusation was made after he mentioned to an employee he and his wife, a front line worker in a care home, had tested positive for Covid-19 in March 2020, upon which both had isolated.
Mr Kearney, who appeared with Aisling Woods, of Tiernan Solicitors, said Mr Molisak felt he had been defamed in front of customers in the store and among the Polish community in Kildare Town.
Counsel for Lidl, Shane English, who appeared with MacSweeney Solicitors, said the company “denied absolutely” that such words had been said to Mr Molisak.
In awarding Mr Molisak (43), of Ruanbeg Court, Kildare Town, damages of €12,500, Judge McCourt said that at the time the entire country was paranoid and on tenterhooks, and people were looked upon with suspicion when they went about any business they had to do.
“It was an appalling time,” Judge McCourt said. “Most of us remember what it was like to walk down the street and see people step off the footpath.”
Positive test
Check-out operator Renata Terefenko said Mr Molisak was known to the staff and he had told her he and his wife had tested positive for Covid. After she dealt with him, she had gone to the bathroom and washed her hands, the court heard.
She said she rang a colleague, Joanna Stachowicz, who she had seen earlier speaking with Mr Molisak’s wife, to tell her of the development.
Ms Stachowicz told the court she became stressed following the phone call because when she had spoken to Mr Molisak’s wife she had told her she was awaiting test results. She had reported the matter to her manager, Nicoleta Sandru.
Ms Sandru told Judge McCourt she had spoken to Mr Molisak. “I said please don’t tell staff you have Covid as we are under a lot of stress. It is very important for us not to know.”
She said there had been no guidelines in place and every day there was a different message and different rules. If people had come in telling staff they had Covid, they would have had to close, she claimed.
Ms Sandru denied having said to Molisak: “You are spreading the coronavirus and you must leave the premises.”
Judge McCourt said he had no doubt all of the witnesses were doing their best to relay what they recalled, and he commended all of them for their efforts to persuade him as to the merits of their respective cases.
You probably couldn’t find a better company highly recommend Mark Tiernan for he’s outstanding work which other Solicitors couldn’t take on and achieve the best outcome.
Mark and his team got me through a very long and tedious case with a former employer. They kept me up to date on the case, accepted calls and emails in a timely manor and talked me through the process and what I should do. I would highly recommend Tiernan Solicitors for personal injury cases
A professional & friendly service provided by Tiernan & CO Solicitors. My case was well managed by June with an excellent result. I would highly recommend.
I would highly recommend using Tiernan Personal Injury Solicitors. June, Mark and the team have been brilliant to deal with. I had a serious road traffic accident that required their services. Throughout the whole process , the help and guidance I was given with a personal touch made finish extremely happy with the level of expertise I received.
I found Tiernan Solictors to be Fantastic from start to finish.I dealt with Aisling who was incredibly efficient and I would highly recommend this firm to anyone.
I used Tiernan & Co. Solicitors for my personal injury claim. Extremely professional, friendly and efficient from start to finish. Thanks so much to all the team for a great outcome. Would highly recommend.
I would like to thank everyone at Tiernan and Co Solicitors for their excellent work, professionalism, kindness, and a special thank you to Aisling Woods for her friendly and accessible manner. I was always lent a sympathetic ear which was very much appreciated.I would highly recommend Tiernan and Co Solicitors and many thanks again for everything, you were brilliant”
I'd highly recommend Tiernan Solicitors , I dealt with June O'Neill mainly but there is a backroom team who go unnoticed and they deserve a lot of credit. Despite many interruptions like Covid , stalling of legal issues etc , June kept me in the loop and we finally had our day in court. Everything was well prepared and we secured a successful outcome . I would have no problem using Tiernan Solicitors in the future.
Recently had to use the services of Tiernan and Co Solicitors and found them very professional in dealing with my case. June O’Neill and her team are very friendly and extremely efficient in what they do. I highly recommend using their services.
I engaged Tiernan solicitors in 2013, while my case was a slow process and only resolved now happily I might add., I cannot fault their professionalism throughout all my dealings. In particular June was always on hand to advise and answer any query.I would be happy to use their services again.
I just want to say thank you to all the team but especially Aisling who was dealing with my case. This was my first time having to seek legal advice. I was guided through the whole process and everything was explained in detail. There was always a speedy response to any queries I may have had. I am very happy with the outcome of my case and I am delighted that I chose Tiernan Personal Injury Solicitors. Highly recommend!
Tiernan Solicitors are a great team to have on your side, they made everyhing very easy! Great attention to detail on their behalf. Aisling and Roisin were brilliant!
Best RepresentationHaving never required legal services before, I did not know what to expect from a solicitor. I approached Tiernan & Co about a personal injuries claim, and suffice to say I was blown away. Every single person that I spoke to was helpful, informative, understanding, and attentive. The standard of work they hold themselves too is unlike anything I had ever experienced. I would like to mention Mrs. Aisling Woods in particular. Through every stage of my case I felt like I was her top priority. The legal system can be intimidating if you are not familiar with it, but Aisling made sure that I fully understood every step of the process. At the time of the trial Mark Tiernan provided the best representation I could have possibly hoped for. As it was a new experience for me, I was quite nervous. The team made me feel so calm and reassured that I was in safe hands. Anyone seeking a solicitors firm should look no further than Tiernan & Co. Solicitors!
Aisling helped me navigate a settlement process in such a calm and professional way that it removed any anxiety and stress I may have had. I really felt like I had somebody in my corner. She is an absolute credit to Tiernan & Co. I wish her every success in the future.
Just wanted to Thank Tiernan and CompanySolicitors and particularly Aisling Woods my solicitor so professional and supportive in looking after my claim and myself. Great to deal with and would definitely recommend.
I've recently used Tiernan Solicitors and initially dealt with Mark who was very supportive in taking on our case back in 2018.Aisling Woods was the solicitor dealing with our case. She was simply fantastic at all stages of handling the claim and kept us up to date and informed with the progress of the case on a regular basis.Aisling and all the team dealt with the case in such a professional manner and has acted in our best interest at all times - the work she put into our case definitely resulted in a very satisfactory outcome.Best of luck for the future Mark, Aisling and all at Tiernans.A & E Tucker
For someone like me who's never been in a situation needing legal representation, i was feeling very apprehensive of what's going to happen. Tiernan Solicitors made everything easy; every phone and email conversation with June O'Neill is explained in details making me feel comfortable throughout this lengthy process. To everyone at Tiernan Solicitors who worked professionally on my case, a million thanks for helping me.
Aisling was dealing with my case over the past few months, she was so helpful and professional and made the situation I was dealing with easier, and I was very grateful for that.
I would totally recommend Tiernan and Co Solicitors. I found Aisling Woods extremely helpful and supportive after my RTA and all throughout my case dealing with legal matters.Aisling was very helpful, always keeping me informed and up to date. Thank you for such friendly and professional serviceP Griffin
Highly recommend June O’Neill of Tiernan & Co. She handled a recent matter for me in the most professional way, as well as being friendly and efficient!
Can't recommend enough! So easy to deal with, they took care of everything all I had to do is show up on the day. I'd like to mention June who looked after me, great communication with her and put me at ease immediately on the day. Brilliant outcome, can't thank them enough!
I hurt my back after I fell down some stairs , at first I didn't want to pursue legal action but when i was still in pain nearly a year later and hadn't been able to return to work I decided to and I'm glad I did.. Aisling woods was my solicitor and she was amazing she reassured me the whole way and talked me true everything .she was very good and very easy to deal with and very professional . I'd like to thank everyone who delt with my case for all your time and hard work use where all amazing thank use all so much .
Can't recommend June O’Neill in Tiernan & Co. enough. She recently handled a matter for me and she was highly professional and friendly throughout. June is extremely efficient and made the process very easy.
Ms Aisling wood is very sufficient in dealing with my case , very helpful and got me a good settlement , highly recommend Tiernan solicitors and ms Aisling wood .
I'm incredibly grateful for the exceptional assistance provided by June who handled my case. Her expertise, attention to detail, and unwavering support significantly contributed to a favorable outcome for us both.I cannot thank her enough for navigating the complexities of my case with professionalism and skill. I would highly recommend her for anyone seeking legal advice.
Really happy with this company and especially aisling. She was really helpful and prompt and kindly reassured me at any point where I was unsure about anything. She was really quick to respond and to get my settlement money. I am really pleased so thank you.
I Highly recommend Tiernan Solicitors especially June who looked after my case guided me through the process and kept me updated through email and made sure i knew what was happening every step of way. June's professionalism.and communication was 100%. A job well done and a fantastic end result.
Cannot recommend enough, from start to finish fantastic communication, clear advice, quick response. Completely hassle free. They handled a personal injury for me and I had complete confidence in them from their honest opinion and advice. Highly recommend.
Having employed tiernan &Co Solicitors for my personal injury case,I can say that although it took a while for my case to be settled, due to the covid years, I am very happy with the service they provided, they really came through for me in the end and fought that bit harder, they truly were on my side and made the process easy enough. I would particularly like to mention June O'Neill, who was brilliant, and the barrister that took my case was a star .
Couldn't recommend these enough especially June. She dealt with my case so professionally n kept in touch with me the whole way through highly highly recommend excellent service n communication.
I had a great experience with Tiernan Personal Injury Solicitors. I first contacted Mark in 2020 in relation to a hand injury and after a few minutes of speaking in detail about the incident he decided to take my case. It has recently come to a closure which I’m very happy with. I would recommend Mark to anyone with a similar case as I felt from the beginning it was in the right hands. Marks professional guidance throughout my case was abundant and I was getting regular feedback throughout the entire process.
I have been dealing with Tiernan and Co since 2018. June O’Neill and her team are absolutely fantastic from day one. Amazing representation. Extremely professional and understanding. I cannot recommend them highly enough.
Their dedication to my case was top notch. June was so concerned and kept giving me advice on how to make a stronger case so I get properly taken care of. I am grateful to everyone at Tiernan solicitors.
I highly recommend Tiernan Personal Injury Solicitors.I would like to mention Sarah Dunne and June O'Neill who looked after my case and guided me through the process.They were very professional , they keep me updated and answered all my questions all the time.They always replied through the mails or phone calls.My case is done and results are great!!! I highly recommendedExcellent service
I can not recommend Tiernan solicitors highly enough. The entire process was painless thanks to all of the staff in the office. A special thank you to Roisin and Mark for always taking my calls and the end result.